Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Don’t Diagnose Your Ex

Almost every client who consults with me complains about their ex. Sally from Minnetonka, Minnesota is typical. “John is very controlling and narcissistic. He thinks only about himself, and he can do no wrong.” I asked her if her ex had been diagnosed with Narcissistic Personality Disorder. She shrugged. “I don’t know. I was reading about it on the internet and John fits the description very well.” I smiled.

As reviewed Sally’s case, I agreed that John’s behavior appeared to be controlling, and he did, in fact, show little insight into Sally’s feelings. However, I am a lawyer. I’m not a psychologist. Sally’s characterization of her ex does help me understand the dynamic of her particular case, but it also sets a self-fulfilling expectation for future conduct. The diagnosis establishes in Sally’s mind that there is something “wrong” with John. His future actions will be viewed through that filter.

Co-parenting is really hard when you think something is wrong with the other parent. Consider Molly, a woman from Maple Grove, Minnesota who came to me because her ex-husband had filed a motion to change custody, because two of their four children were having problems in school. Her ex-husband believed the problems were caused by Molly’s depression. Certainly, Molly hadn’t had the most stable of living situations. However, as I delved deeper into her case, Molly was a loving mother who had a lot of strengths as a parent. She was very involved in her children’s lives, and she did her best to help her children with school, but it just wasn’t her strength. When we mediated, I discovered that Molly’s ex-husband was also a perfectly reasonable person who had fallen into the trap of viewing his children’s problems as a symptom of his ex’s diagnosis. In that case, we were able to use a therapeutic approach to help the parents understand and address their children’s psychological and education needs.

As a Family Law attorney Minnesota, it is my job to help my client use the legal system to resolve disputes when the parents have separated. I find it useful to understand how my clients view the other side of the case. But permanent solutions almost always require my client to co-parent despite the faults of the other parent.


About Author

Jennifer graduated from the University of Minnesota cum laude with a bachelor’s degree in speech communications. In 2006, Jennifer achieved her life’s dream; owning her own family Law Attorney Minnesota practice. She practices every day as Divorce attorney MN with the intention of representing her clients’ future.

No comments:

Post a Comment